← All communities
Reddit community

r/mtgrules

46.1K members. The best post we have captured here reached 733 upvotes, which works out to 16 per 1,000 members.

16peak upvotes per 1,000 members
46.1Kmembers
733best post
288most comments
102posts we track

Open r/mtgrules on Reddit β†—

What actually lands here

The mix of post types among everything we have captured. Posting a link where almost nothing but images lands is wasted effort, and this is the fastest way to see it.

55% 42%
Question 55% Text 42% Image 2% Gallery 1%

What the ceiling looks like

The biggest posts we have captured here. Links go to the original on Reddit.

Opponent Counters "whatever I'm playing"

↑ 733 πŸ’¬ 226 text 2025

Countering a resolved creature spell because it attacked

↑ 585 πŸ’¬ 267 text 2025

offered pack to remove a EDH player

↑ 484 πŸ’¬ 168 text 2025

Why is [[Skullclamp]] considered to be such a good card?

↑ 448 πŸ’¬ 160 question 2025

I run EDH tournaments and one of my players said this was legal

↑ 420 πŸ’¬ 119 text 2025

Trample and Deathtouch, need a literal ruling

↑ 412 πŸ’¬ 103 text 2025

Opponent tried to blame me for his mistake

↑ 336 πŸ’¬ 67 text 2024

Have I been playing Evolving Wilds wrong for 11 years?

↑ 304 πŸ’¬ 180 question 2025

Can an opponent "respond" to me declaring attackers?

↑ 292 πŸ’¬ 288 question 2025

Big change to combat damage with Foundations.

↑ 267 πŸ’¬ 240 text 2024

Communities its size

Within four times the member count either way, so the comparison is fair. Sorted by upside.

See what is climbing here before you write

ViralHunt tracks Reddit and eight other networks, records how every post grows, and puts what is taking off in front of your team in one list.

Start free β†’

Every figure here is what ViralHunt has captured from r/mtgrules, not everything the community has ever posted. We deliberately do not publish an average score: our sample is weighted toward a community's best posts, so an average would be flattering and wrong. Peak per 1,000 members is computed the same way for every community listed. See how we measure.